Meet the Contenders
"Hey There Pumpkin" – The Playful Welcomer
The Vibe: Friendly, fun, and full of autumn cheer
The Message: A warm, casual greeting that makes everyone smile
Best Personality Match: If your decorating style is "cozy farmhouse with a side of whimsy"
"Give Thanks" – The Gratitude Keeper
The Vibe: Meaningful, traditional, and heartwarming
The Message: A beautiful reminder to appreciate life's blessings
Best Personality Match: If you love "purposeful decor that tells a story"
Side-by-Side Comparison
| Feature | Hey There Pumpkin | Give Thanks |
|---|---|---|
| Size | 17" diameter | 17" diameter |
| Message Style | Playful greeting | Inspirational reminder |
| Pumpkin Count | 3 pumpkins | 5 pumpkins |
| Color Palette | Orange, cream, burgundy | Orange, yellow, burgundy, sage, peach |
| Design Elements | Rustic fence backdrop | Decorative vines & leaves |
| Script Style | Casual brush script | Elegant script + block letters |
| Best Season | September - October | October - November |
| Ideal Placement | Entryway, living room, anywhere fun | Dining room, kitchen, gathering spaces |
| Perfect For | Everyday fall decorating | Thanksgiving celebrations |
| Mood | Cheerful & welcoming | Warm & grateful |
| Price | $39.99 | $39.99 |
The Color Story: What Makes Each Unique
"Hey There Pumpkin" Color Palette
This sign features a classic autumn trio:
- Crisp cream/white pumpkin for that modern farmhouse touch
- Deep burgundy pumpkin adding rich, jewel-tone sophistication
- Vibrant orange pumpkin bringing traditional fall energy
- Golden script text that catches the light beautifully
- Natural wood fence silhouette creating rustic depth
What it pairs with: Buffalo check patterns, copper accents, cream and white neutrals, traditional fall orange
The overall feel: Clean, classic autumn with a rustic twist
"Give Thanks" Color Palette
This sign offers a fuller, more diverse autumn rainbow:
- Bright pumpkin orange as the showstopping star
- Sunny cream yellow adding cheerful warmth
- Rich burgundy wine for depth and elegance
- Soft sage green bringing a fresh, unexpected touch
- Peachy coral for subtle warmth
- Dark espresso wood border framing it all beautifully
What it pairs with: Jewel tones, mixed metallics, maximalist fall displays, traditional Thanksgiving tables
The overall feel: Abundant, celebratory, full of color and life
Design Details That Matter
"Hey There Pumpkin" Design Elements
The Fence Backdrop:
One of the most distinctive features is the silhouette fence that creates a layered, dimensional look. It's like looking at pumpkins sitting on a rustic farm fence – storytelling through design!
The Typography:
"HEY THERE" in bold, uppercase letters demands attention, while "pumpkin" flows in an elegant script. This combination of fonts adds visual interest and playful contrast.
The Simplicity:
With three pumpkins and clean design elements, this sign has a "less is more" philosophy that works beautifully in minimalist or modern farmhouse spaces.
"Give Thanks" Design Elements
The Vine Details:
Intricate pumpkin vines wind across the top with delicate tendrils and cut-out leaves. These details create beautiful shadows when light hits the sign from different angles.
The Scattered Accents:
Tiny leaf cutouts and decorative elements scattered around the base add whimsy and movement. Your eye travels around the entire piece discovering new details.
The Typography:
"GIVE" in clean block letters provides stability, while "Thanks" flows in gorgeous script. This combination feels both grounded and graceful – much like gratitude itself!
The Abundance:
Five pumpkins of varying sizes create a bountiful harvest feeling. There's a fullness to this design that celebrates autumn's abundance.
When to Choose "Hey There Pumpkin"
Choose this sign if you:
✓ Start decorating for fall in early September
This sign works from the first hint of autumn all the way through October. It's not specifically Thanksgiving-themed, so you get more weeks of display time!
✓ Love playful, casual design
The friendly greeting and whimsical style work perfectly if your decorating personality leans toward "cozy and fun" rather than "formal and traditional."
✓ Have a neutral color scheme
With its classic three-color palette, this sign is easier to coordinate with cream, white, and neutral-heavy decorating schemes.
✓ Want an entryway statement piece
"Hey There Pumpkin" is essentially saying "welcome!" – making it perfect for greeting guests at your front door or in your foyer.
✓ Prefer minimalist farmhouse style
If you lean toward the "modern farmhouse" aesthetic with clean lines and uncluttered spaces, this sign's simpler design will feel right at home.
✓ Are decorating a smaller space
While both signs are the same size, the simpler design reads as slightly less busy, making it great for smaller walls or spaces.
When to Choose "Give Thanks"
Choose this sign if you:
✓ Go all-out for Thanksgiving
This is THE sign for Thanksgiving enthusiasts. The message is perfect for the gratitude season and sets the tone for your holiday celebrations.
✓ Love color and detail
With five different pumpkin colors and intricate vine details, this sign satisfies those who love visual richness and layers of interest.
✓ Want meaningful decor
If you prefer your decorations to carry a message or inspiration, "Give Thanks" offers a daily reminder of what matters most.
✓ Decorate your dining spaces
This sign is ideal above a dining table, in the kitchen, or anywhere your family gathers to share meals and make memories.
✓ Appreciate traditional Thanksgiving aesthetics
The abundant harvest imagery and gratitude message align perfectly with traditional Thanksgiving themes and values.
✓ Want year-round potential
While perfect for fall, many people keep "Give Thanks" displayed year-round as a constant gratitude reminder. Try that with a sign that says "pumpkin spice"!
Best Placement Ideas for Each Sign
"Hey There Pumpkin" Shines In:
1. The Entryway
Lean it on a console table with a collection of small pumpkins. It's the perfect friendly greeting for guests.
2. Above the Mantel
Center it as your fall focal point with simple, complementary decor on the mantel below.
3. Kitchen Open Shelving
Prop it behind your everyday dishes for a seasonal kitchen update that doesn't require a complete overhaul.
4. Covered Front Porch
Display it next to your front door with mums and hay bales for ultimate curb appeal.
5. Bedroom or Reading Nook
Add autumn coziness to personal spaces where you relax and unwind.
"Give Thanks" Belongs In:
1. Dining Room Focal Point
Hang it on the wall where everyone can see it during family dinners and Thanksgiving feasts.
2. Kitchen Command Center
Place it where your family gathers daily – above the breakfast table or on a kitchen wall.
3. Thanksgiving Table Centerpiece
Lay it flat in the center of your dining table surrounded by candles and small gourds.
4. Living Room Gallery Wall
Incorporate it into a wall of family photos and meaningful artwork.
5. Buffet or Sideboard Display
Lean it as the backdrop for your Thanksgiving serving area or bar cart.
Styling Each Sign: A Designer's Guide
Styling "Hey There Pumpkin"
Go for clean and simple:
- Pair with 3-5 real or faux pumpkins in the same colors (white, orange, burgundy)
- Add one tall element (candlestick, vase with branches)
- Include soft texture (throw blanket, linen napkin)
- Keep it uncluttered – let the sign be the star
Color coordination:
- Cream/ivory throws and pillows
- Copper or brass metallic accents
- Natural wood elements
- Classic buffalo check in orange or black
Perfect pairings:
- White ceramic pumpkins
- Dried pampas grass or wheat
- Simple white candles
- Rustic wooden bowls
Styling "Give Thanks"
Embrace abundance:
- Create a full pumpkin display with 5-7 pumpkins in varied sizes
- Layer in multiple textures (burlap, velvet, wood)
- Add lush elements (eucalyptus, fall florals, garland)
- Build height with candlesticks at varying levels
Color coordination:
- Pull from all five pumpkin colors in your surrounding decor
- Mix warm metallics (gold, bronze, copper)
- Layer patterns (plaid, stripes, florals)
- Add jewel-tone accents
Perfect pairings:
- Colorful Indian corn
- Rich burgundy or plum candles
- Copper lanterns
- Vintage brass candlesticks
- Abundant fall foliage
The Timeline: When to Display Each
September Display Strategy
Early September (Labor Day - Mid-Month):
- "Hey There Pumpkin" ✓ Perfect!
- "Give Thanks" - A bit early (save it for later)
Late September:
- "Hey There Pumpkin" ✓ Still going strong
- "Give Thanks" ✓ Can start introducing it
October Display Strategy
Early-Mid October:
- "Hey There Pumpkin" ✓ Peak season!
- "Give Thanks" ✓ Great time to bring it out
Late October (Halloween Week):
- "Hey There Pumpkin" ✓ Works well (not Halloween-specific)
- "Give Thanks" ✓ Perfect transition piece
November Display Strategy
Early November (Thanksgiving Prep):
- "Hey There Pumpkin" - Starting to transition out
- "Give Thanks" ✓ Prime time!
Thanksgiving Week:
- "Hey There Pumpkin" - Time to pack away
- "Give Thanks" ✓ Absolute star of the show
Post-Thanksgiving:
- "Give Thanks" - Can keep up or transition to Christmas
- Both signs get lovingly stored for next year!
The "Why Not Both?" Strategy
Here's the truth: these signs complement each other beautifully! Here's how to display both in your home:
Option 1: Room Division
- "Hey There Pumpkin" in the living room or entryway
- "Give Thanks" in the dining room or kitchen
- They create a cohesive fall theme throughout your home
Option 2: Sequential Display
- September-October: Feature "Hey There Pumpkin"
- Late October-November: Switch to "Give Thanks"
- You get 12+ weeks of fresh fall decor!
Option 3: The Collection Approach
- Display both together on a large wall or mantel
- They're the same size, so they create perfect symmetry
- Mix the pumpkins and decor elements from both color palettes
- Creates an impressive "autumn gallery" effect
Option 4: Give One as a Gift
- Keep your favorite for yourself
- Gift the other to a friend, family member, or hostess
- Spread the autumn joy (and maybe start a tradition!)
What Our Customers Are Saying
"Hey There Pumpkin" Reviews:
"I get compliments every single time someone comes to my door! It's the perfect welcoming piece." – Rachel T., Broken Arrow, OK
"Love how it's fun but not tacky. Feels high-quality and the layered wood is gorgeous in person." – Michelle K., Tulsa, OK
"I put it up September 1st and leave it till Halloween. Gets me in the fall mood every time I see it!" – Jennifer M., Oklahoma City, OK
"Give Thanks" Reviews:
"This is now the centerpiece of our Thanksgiving table every year. My kids ask about it in August!" – Sarah P., Bixby, OK
"The colors are even prettier in person. I love all the little details in the vines and leaves." – Amanda R., Owasso, OK
"Such a beautiful daily reminder. I actually keep mine up year-round in my kitchen." – Lisa W., Jenks, OK
The Craftsmanship Story
Both signs are handcrafted in our Tulsa, Oklahoma workshop using the same quality materials and techniques:
Precision Laser Cutting:
Each layer is cut with exact precision, ensuring perfect alignment and professional edges.
Hand-Painted Details:
While we use technology for cutting, the painting is done with care to ensure rich, even color.
Quality Materials:
We use premium wood that won't warp or crack, and paints that maintain their vibrant colors season after season.
Attention to Detail:
From the delicate vine tendrils to the subtle wood grain showing through, every detail is intentional.
Since 1949:
We've been in the engraving and crafting business for over 75 years. That experience shows in every piece.
Making Your Decision: The Quick Quiz
Still not sure? Answer these quick questions:
1. What's your primary fall decorating goal?
- A) Create a warm, welcoming atmosphere ➜ Hey There Pumpkinfall-decor
- B) Celebrate Thanksgiving and gratitude ➜ Give Thanks
2. What's your color preference?
- A) Classic autumn with neutral touches ➜ Hey There Pumpkin
- B) Full spectrum of fall colors ➜ Give Thanks
3. When do you start decorating?
- A) As soon as September hits! ➜ Hey There Pumpkin
- B) Mid-October through Thanksgiving ➜ Give Thanks
4. What's your decorating style?
- A) Modern farmhouse, clean lines ➜ Hey There Pumpkin
- B) Traditional, abundant, layered ➜ Give Thanks
5. Where will you display it?
- A) Entryway, living room, porch ➜ Hey There Pumpkin
- B) Dining room, kitchen, gathering space ➜ Give Thanks
6. What matters most to you?
- A) Fun, cheerful, welcoming ➜ Hey There Pumpkin
- B) Meaningful, inspirational, traditional ➜ Give Thanks
Care & Storage for Both Signs
Since these signs are handcrafted wood pieces, they'll last for many seasons with proper care:
During Display:
- Dust weekly with a soft, dry cloth
- Keep away from direct moisture
- Avoid direct sunlight to prevent fading
- Best for indoor or covered outdoor use
Storage Tips:
- Store flat or carefully propped (don't stack heavy items on top)
- Keep in a cool, dry place
- Wrap in tissue paper or bubble wrap
- Store in original packaging if possible
- Label your storage box so you can find it easily next year!
Both signs maintain their beauty year after year with minimal maintenance.
The Technical Specs Reminder
Both signs share these features:
- Size: 17" diameter x 0.25" thick
- Weight: Approximately 1.5 lbs (lightweight and easy to hang)
- Material: Layered wood with painted details
- Hanging Options: Sawtooth hanger (standard), twine hanger, or bow hanger
- Price: $39.99 + shipping
- Handcrafted: In Tulsa, Oklahoma
- Business: Woman-owned, established 1949
Bundle & Save Opportunity
Want both signs?
Contact us about bundle pricing! Email info@bhengraving.com or call (918) 582-1165 to ask about:
- Multi-sign discounts
- Holiday gift sets
- Coordinated hanging options
- Custom packaging for gifts
The Final Verdict
There's truly no wrong choice here – both signs are beautiful, well-crafted pieces that will bring autumn joy to your home.
Choose "Hey There Pumpkin" if: You want playful, versatile fall decor that works from September through October with a casual, welcoming vibe.
Choose "Give Thanks" if: You're passionate about Thanksgiving, love colorful abundant displays, and want meaningful decor that celebrates gratitude.
Choose both if: You want to enjoy different aspects of fall throughout the entire season, have multiple rooms to decorate, or want to build a collection of coordinating pieces.
Remember: these are handcrafted pieces you'll treasure for years. They're not just seasonal decorations – they're investments in the cozy, welcoming atmosphere you create in your home.
Ready to Welcome Fall Home?
Shop the Collection:
🎃 "Hey There Pumpkin" Wood Sign → $39.99
🍂 "Give Thanks" Wood Sign → $39.99